Effect Of Poor Accounting Record On The Performance Of Small Enterprises In Makurdi Local Government Area Of Benue State

Effect Of Poor Accounting Record On The Performance Of Small Enterprises In Makurdi Local Government Area Of Benue State (Charles)
Abstract
This study was carried out to examine the effect of poor accounting records on the performance of small enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State. The study was specifically carried out to determine the effect of poor accounting records on effective decision-making in small enterprises in Makurdi LGA, assess the effect of poor accounting records on the operational efficiency of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA, evaluate the effect of poor accounting records on the financial performance of small enterprises, and analyze the effect of poor accounting records on the growth and sustainability of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA. The study employed the descriptive survey research design. Hence, the questionnaire was used for data collection, while the data collected were analyzed using descriptive statistics such as mean and standard deviation, and inferential statistics using simple linear regression for hypothesis testing. The population of the study consists of 1,248 registered small enterprise owners operating within Makurdi Local Government Area. A sample size of 303 respondents was determined using Taro Yamane formula, with a validated sample of 288 respondents, and the multi-stage sampling technique involving stratified and convenience sampling was employed to select participants. From the responses obtained and analyzed, the findings revealed that poor accounting records have a significant effect on effective decision-making at β = 0.68, R² = 0.4624, P = 0.0001, operational efficiency at β = 0.65, R² = 0.423, P = 0.0001, financial performance at β = 0.70, R² = 0.490, P = 0.0002, and growth and sustainability at β = 0.67, R² = 0.449, P = 0.0003 of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA. The study therefore recommends that small enterprise owners should be trained on proper accounting and record-keeping practices, government agencies should provide affordable accounting tools and software, owners should regularly monitor financial and operational reports, and policymakers should design programs that promote financial literacy, accountability, and structured reporting among small enterprises.
Table of Content
Chapter One
Introduction
- 1.1 Background of the Study
- 1.2 Statement of the Problem
- 1.3 Objective of the Study
- 1.4 Research Questions
- 1.5 Research Questions
- 1.6 Significance of the Study
- 1.7 Scope of the Study
- 1.8 Definition of Terms
Chapter Two
Review of Literature
- 2.1 Conceptual Framework
- 2.2 Theoretical Framework
- 2.3 Empirical Review
- 2.4 Summary of Literature Review
Chapter Three
Introduction
- 3.0 Introduction
- 3.1 Research Design
- 3.2 Population of the Study
- 3.3 Sample Size
- 3.4 Sampling Technique
- 3.5 Instrument for Data Collection
- 3.6 Validity of the Instrument
- 3.7 Reliability of the Instrument
- 3.8 Method Of Data Collection
- 3.9 Method of Data Analysis
- 3.10 Ethical Consideration
Chapter Four
Introduction
- 4.0 Introduction
- 4.2 Analysis of the effect of poor accounting records
- 4.3 Analysis of the effective decision-making in small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
- 4.4 Analysis of the operational efficiency of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
- 4.5 Analysis of the financial performance of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA
- 4.6 Analysis of the growth and sustainability of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
- 4.7 Test of Hypotheses
- 4.8 Discussion of Finding
Chapter Five
Introduction
- 5.1 Introduction
- 5.2 Summary
- 5.3 Conclusion
- 5.4 Limitations of the Study
- 5.5 Recommendations
- 5.6 Suggestions for Further Studies
- Appendix
- References
Chapter One
Introduction
1.1 Background of the Study
The basic foundation of economic activity in the countries is the efficient coordination of resources, institutions, and information systems that promote production and exchange. Economic decision-making, especially the financial information, has continued to be a central aspect of both macro and micro economic decisions. Oyedokun et al. (2022) argue that accounting information offers a systematic way of identifying, measuring, and communicating economic events to be judged. Similarly, Nangih et al. (2021) elaborate that the development of accounting practice is in line with the increase in the complexity of economic interactions in contemporary societies. These views indicate that accounting is not only a technical routine but also a systemic role, which supports organisational sustainability. Adegbayibi (2025) also adds that with the growth of economies, there is an increase in the need of credible financial information, which defines how enterprises plan, control, and assess activities in competitive settings.
Expanding on this wider economic base, small enterprises are strategically placed in terms of generating employment, income distribution and integrating local economies. Small enterprises are typically described as businesses that are owned independently and have a small capital base, workforce, and scope of operations but have a significant contribution to economic liveliness (Ayoola-Akinjobi, 2025). In these organizations, accounting records are formal records of financial transactions, such as sales, expenses, assets and liabilities, over a specified period of time. Mbogo et al. (2023) suggest that accounting records are the memory of an enterprise that keeps financial history to be referred to and analyzed. In this case, performance refers to the level of efficiency, profitability, growth, and sustainability of an enterprise. As Akintayo et al. (2025) note, these notions are connected with each other because record-keeping structures affect the way performance outcomes are measured and understood.
Since businesses are in a dynamic and resource-bound environment, accounting records quality becomes an inherent part of organisational performance orientation. According to Sabore (2025), accounting records support planning, coordination, and evaluation activities in enterprises through provision of credible financial indications. On the same note, Damascene and Kasozi (2025) note that well-organized accounting systems increase internal accountability and strategic alignment, which determine the outcome of an enterprise. The connection between accounting documents and performance is thus conceptual, in the sense that financial information can be used to make informed managerial decisions and not isolated technical compliance. This opinion is supported by Adegbayibi (2025), who states that the enterprises that have consistent accounting systems are in a better position to analyze the outcomes of operations and correlate them with the long-term goals. This story places accounting records as a part and parcel of enterprise operations.
In the developing economies, the applicability of accounting records to the performance of small enterprises takes localised dimensions that are influenced by institutional and socio-economic contexts. Small businesses constitute a significant part of economic activity in Nigeria especially at the local government level (Ayoola-Akinjobi, 2025). The Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State is a good example of a business environment where small businesses are involved in trade, services, and agro-allied businesses. Akintayo et al. (2025) state that contextual factors determine the adoption and usage of accounting practices in such environments. Oyedokun et al. (2022) observe that the analysis of accounting records in particular localities allows better understanding of their relationship with the performance of enterprises. This paper thus limits itself to Makurdi Local Government Area, which serves as a contextual background to the analysis of the impact of accounting records on the performance of small enterprises.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Small enterprises continue to be a centre of policy discussion and research, due to their supposed contribution to inclusive economic growth and the sustainability of local economies. In many developing environments, these businesses are viewed as the major channels of job creation and generation of income. As Ayoola-Akinjobi (2025) notes, the continuity of small businesses is inseparably connected with internal mechanisms that are used to plan and control; accounting, as a formal tool of financial activities recording, is central to these. Oyedokun et al. (2022) argue that accounting information enhances the visibility of organizations and their decision-making consistency in the case of a judicious use of such information, whereas Akintayo et al. (2025) state that the systematic financial information systems are essential to evaluate the performance of enterprises over time. Taken together, these views highlight the relevance of accounting systems in the management of enterprises without singling out operational shortcomings.
As a matter of fact, the current situation of most small businesses demonstrates a weak alignment between accounting and performance results. Mbogo et al. (2023) note that such key performance indicators as profitability, liquidity stability, and growth consistency are often poorly monitored, based on poor accounting records. Sabore (2025) goes on to explain that incomplete or damaged records hinder the ability of enterprises to assess financial position and operational efficiency. The small enterprises ought to preferably keep proper, up to date, and complete accounting records that can be used to evaluate performance and strategic direction (Damascene & Kasozi, 2025). This apparent gap between current accounting practices and this ideal standard suggests a disconnection that affects the way the performance of enterprises is measured, interpreted, and maintained over time.
Although there is growing concern on the development of small-enterprises, the available studies provide minimal empirical clarification on the quantitative impact of poor accounting records on performance outcomes in localized settings. According to Nangih et al. (2021), the majority of the evidence that is available is generalized, thus providing a lack of context-specific information. According to Adegbayibi (2025), the differences in the local economic environments also require an intensive analysis to explain the performance differentials. The scope of the effect of poor accounting records on the quantifiable performance measures is under-researched in the Makurdi Local Government Area of the Benue State. In this respect, the research will be used to fill the knowledge gap by conducting a systematic analysis of how accounting records have poor performance on the performance of small enterprises in this locale to add context-specific evidence to the literature.
1.3 Objective of the Study
The main purpose of this study is to examine effect of poor accounting record on the performance of small enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area Of Benue State.
The specific objectives of the study seek to:
- To determine the effect of poor accounting records on the effective decision-making in small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
- To determine the effect of poor accounting records on the operational efficiency of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
- To determine the effect of poor accounting records on the financial performance of small enterprises
- To determine the effect of poor accounting records on the growth and sustainability of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
1.4 Research Questions
The study will be guided by the following questions;
- What is the effect of poor accounting records on the effective decision-making in small enterprises in Makurdi LGA?
- What is the effect of poor accounting records on the operational efficiency of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA?
- What is the effect of poor accounting records on the financial performance of small enterprises?
- What is the effect of poor accounting records on the growth and sustainability of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA?
1.5 Research Hypotheses
- H₀₁: Poor accounting records have no significant effect on effective decision-making in small enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area.
- H₀₂: Poor accounting records have no significant effect on the operational efficiency of small enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area.
- H₀₃: Poor accounting records have no significant effect on the financial performance of small enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area.
- H₀₄: Poor accounting records have no significant effect on the growth and sustainability of small enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area.
1.6 Significance of the Study
This study will be beneficial to the owners and managers of small businesses as it will provide clear understanding on how quality of accounting records affects the performance of the business. It will allow them to capture the practical implications which are associated with the maintenance of appropriate financial records in the assessment of profitability, cash flows and the justification of informed managerial decisions. The empirical evidence will guide the operators of the enterprises to the strengthening of the internal financial practices to increase the efficiency of the operations and the long-term sustainability.
The research will be of great importance to the governmental agencies and policy makers involved in the development of small enterprises. It will make evidence-based knowledge on the impact of accounting record practices on the performance of the enterprise on the local government level. This understanding will be useful in the development of specific policies, training programmes, and regulatory frameworks to improve the financial management capacity of small enterprises.
The financial institutions will find this research useful as they will gain deeper understanding of the role of accounting records in assessing the performance and creditworthiness of small enterprises. The results will help lenders to tighten the loan appraisal, risk assessment, and monitoring of the funded enterprises and hence make more informed and responsible decisions in financing.
The researchers and students in the field of accounting and business-related studies will also find the study useful. It will serve as a source of reference that will increase empirical knowledge on the correlation between accounting records and performance of small enterprises in a localized setting. The study will also trigger subsequent studies by offering a basis of comparative and longitudinal studies.
1.7 Scope of the Study
This study will focus on examining how poor accounting records affect the performance of small business ventures with a special emphasis on financial record-keeping procedures and how they affect profitability, efficiency, and growth. The study is geographically limited to small businesses in the Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State and thus offers a localized setting of the study.
1.8 Operational Definition of Terms
Accounting Records:
The term accounting records is used to mean the orderly records of all financial transactions of a business, sales, expenses, assets and liabilities, which are kept in a way that they can be easily traced and reported to give the financial position of the enterprise.
Small Enterprises:
Privately owned firms that have small capital, human resource, and scope of operations, and are involved in trade, services, or production, and contribute to the local economic development.
Performance:
The quantifiable results of an organization in terms of profitability, growth, efficiency and sustainability within a given time.
Poor Accounting Records: Inefficient, incomplete or inaccurate financial records that do not offer credible information to make decisions, planning or performance appraisal.
Financial Management:
It is the process of planning, organizing, directing and controlling financial activity with the aim of ensuring that the resources are used appropriately and that the enterprise objectives are met.
Profitability:
The capacity of a small business to earn more than it spends in a given period of time, which is a major measure of financial performance.
Efficiency:
The degree to which a small enterprise makes the most out of the available resources to attain the desired results at the lowest possible waste or cost.
Growth:
The growth of a small business in terms of size, capacity or market share, which is an expansion and growth.
Sustainability:
This is the capacity of a small business to be able to continue functioning, make a profit, and still stay afloat in the long run despite the hurdles.
Chapter Five
Summary, Conclusions and Recommendations
5.1 Introduction
This chapter presents a brief overview of the study, summarizes the research process, provides conclusions drawn from the findings, highlights the limitations encountered during the study, offers recommendations for improving the performance of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA, and suggests areas for further research.
5.2 Summary
The study titled “Effect of Poor Accounting Records on the Performance of Small Enterprises in Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State” aimed to examine how inadequate or poor accounting practices influence decision-making, operational efficiency, financial performance, and the growth and sustainability of small enterprises. The specific objectives of the study included determining the effect of poor accounting records on effective decision-making, assessing their influence on operational efficiency, evaluating their impact on financial performance, and analyzing how they affect the growth and sustainability of small enterprises.
The study employed descriptive research design to enable in-depth exploration of the relationship between accounting practices and enterprise performance. The population included 1,248 registered small enterprise owners operating within Makurdi Local Government Area representing different categories of businesses such as trading, manufacturing, services and agro-allied. Using the Taro Yamane formula, a sample size of 303 respondents was first determined and a validated sample of 288 was used for the study. A multi-stage sampling technique that combined stratified and convenience sampling procedures guaranteed the selection of respondents in the various business sectors. Data collection was carried out with the aid of a structured questionnaire with the title “Impact of Poor Accounting Records on Small Enterprises,” and the items of the questionnaire were measured on a five-point Likert scale. Data analysis included descriptive and inferential statistics.
Descriptive analysis used means and standard deviations to identify the degree of agreement on each item on decision-making, operational efficiency, financial performance, and growth and sustainability. Inferential analysis was used with the help of simple linear regression to test the hypotheses and seek the statistical relationship between poor accounting record and each of the dependent variables. The results of the regression analyses showed that there are significant positive associations between poor accounting records and low effectiveness in decision-making, inefficiency in operating the business, poor financial performance, and growth and sustainability. The study found consistent results in which the respondents agreed that the proper accounting records are important for the smooth running of the small enterprises. The standard deviation values showed moderate variability in the responses showing general consensus among the small enterprise owners in the importance of accounting records. The study also showed that poor accounting practices have a direct impact on the ability of enterprise owners to plan, allocate resources efficiently, track revenues and expenses, make timely financial decisions and implement strategies for business growth. Overall, comprehensive evidence was obtained from the study that accounting records are one of the determining factors in the performance of small enterprise in Makurdi LGA and stressed the need for the owners of small enterprise to adopt accurate and systematic accounting practices.
5.3 Conclusion
In conclusion, the study established that the poor accounting records has a significant impact on the performance of small enterprises of Makurdi LGA in the multi-dimension. Effective decision-making, operational efficiency, financial performance, growth and sustainability suffer from poor record keeping. Small enterprise owners who keep proper and accurate accounting records have a better chance of planning properly, making informed business decisions, monitoring performance and continue to grow over time. The findings highlight the vital role that accounting practices play in the development of enterprises, and suggest that better record-keeping could promote the development of a business, its profitability and longevity. The study validates the fact that accounting records are not only a regulatory requirement but a practical tool for successful management and competitiveness in the small business sector.
5.4 Limitations of the Study
Several challenges were faced during the study. First, some respondents did not want to disclose financial information out of fear of disclosure or confidentiality and this limited access to complete data. Second, the time constraints meant that the researcher could not engage a larger number of participants or include all the small enterprises registered and this may affect the research conclusions regarding generalizability. Third, the respondents did not have the same level of understanding of accounting concepts and hence resulted in some inconsistency in the responses of the questionnaire. Fourth, logistical problems, such as transportation problems and problems with arranging visits to scattered business locations, were a problem for data collection. Lastly, few previous researches, specific to small enterprises in Makurdi LGA made it difficult to find literature to review and compare with, and this affected the depth of analysis in the context. Despite these limitations, the study was able to conduct reliable and valid studies by using careful sampling method, validated instrument and a rigorous statistical analysis.
5.5 Recommendations
Based on the findings, the study makes the following recommendations.
- Small enterprise owners should be trained in and shown the correct accounting and record-keeping practices, which would improve decision-making, operational efficiency, and financial management.
- Government agencies and small business development centers should offer affordable and accessible accounting tools and software in order to help maintain good records.
- Enterprise owners should routinely monitor and evaluate their financial statements and operational reports in order to identify areas of inefficiency and take timely improvements.
- Policymakers should develop programs that promote accountability and financial literacy, and structured reporting within small enterprises to ensure that owners are aware of the relationship between the accounting record and long-term sustainability. These recommendations if done will enhance the performance and growth potentials of small enterprises in Makurdi LGA.
5.6 Suggestions for Further Studies
The future studies should investigate the impact of poor accounting record keeping on small enterprises in several local government areas to enhance generalisability and make comparison between formal and informal enterprises.

The Complete Material Will Be Sent to You in Just 2 Steps
Quick & Simple…
![]()
Make Payment (Through Transfer) of ₦6,500 to the Account Below
![]() | Acc No: 0811003731 |
| Samphina Academy | |
| Current Account |
Or CLICK HERE To Pay With Debit Card
| FOR STUDENTS OUTSIDE NIGERIA | |
| CLICK HERE To Pay With Card ($15) | |
| FOR GHANA STUDENTS (GHS 100) | |
![]() | MTN MoMo |
| 0553978005 | |
| Douglas Osabutey | |
![]()
Send the Following Details on WhatsApp ( 07062590260 ) After Payment
- Payment Details
- TOPIC: Effect Of Poor Accounting Record On The Performance Of Small Enterprises In Makurdi Local Government Area Of Benue State
The Complete Material Will Be Sent To You On WhatsApp After Receiving Your Details
T & C Apply
Students Review
List of Related Works
Auditor’s Independence; A Tool For Achieving True And Fair View Of Accounting Records
The Role Accounting Records On The Performance Of Small Scale Industries In Nigeria
The Relevance Of Accounting Records And Survival Of Business Enterprises
A Study Of Accounting Records In Small Scale Business
Evaluating The Efficiency Of Accounting Recording For Doubtful And Bad Debts
The Impact Of Accounting Records On Performance Of Business Organisations
The Role Of Computer In Accounting Record (A Case Of Study Of PHCN Plc, Ilorin)
Accounting Records And Fraud Preventive Measures Amongst Civil Servants
Relevance Of Accounting Records In Small And Medium Scale Industry



