Comparative Study Of The Growth Performance Of Four Commercial Fish Feeds In The Production Of African Catfish

Project and Seminar Material for Fishery and Aquaculture

Comparative Study Of The Growth Performance Of Four Commercial Fish Feeds In The Production Of African Catfish


This research was carried out to determine the best commercial fish feed for the rapid growth and survival of cultured Coppens feed. A total number of sixty four (64) Coppens feed juveniles were used for this study. The juveniles reared were randomly assigned to four dietary treatments: Treatment A ((Vital feed), Treatment B (Multi feed), Treatment C (CHI feed) and Treatment D (Skretting feed). Each treatment was replicated two times in a completely randomized design. The experiment lasted for 9 weeks during which the parameters monitored included weight gain, length increase, percentage weight gain, specific growth rate, food conversion ratio and protein efficiency ratio. The data collected were subjected to analysis of variance at 5% significant level. The results revealed that the highest weight gain was recorded by the fish fed with Skretting feed (73.52g) followed by those fed with Multi feed (58.04g), while least in those fed with CHI (31.92g). The highest length increase was recorded by the fish fed with Skretting (10.97cm) followed by those fed with multi (9.63 cm), while least in those fed with CHI (6.17 cm).The percentage weight gain of Coppens feed fingerlings was highest (691.07) in those fed with Skretting followed by those fed with Multi (539.30) while least in those fed with CHI (300.83).

The specific growth rate of Coppens feed fingerlings was highest (6.82±0.17) in those fed with Skretting followed by those fed with Multi (6.44±0.15) while least in those fed with CHI (5.48±0.34). The best feed conversion ratio was recorded in Coppens feed juveniles fed with Skretting (1.17±0.01) followed by those fed with multi feed (1.23±0.03) while least in those fed with CHI (1.53±0.25). The best value for protein efficiency ratio was recorded in the Coppens feed juveniles fed with the Skretting (1.37±0.11) while the poorest protein efficiency ratio was evident in those fed with CHI (0.95±0.16. The juveniles fed with CHI and Vital feeds had the highest survival (93.75%) while least in those of Skretting and Multi (87.50%). It was concluded that among the four commercial fish feeds studied, Skretting fish feed is the best for rearing Coppens feed in Nigeria.

Chapter One


1.1 Background of the Study

With global population expansion, the demand for high quality animal protein is rising dramatically (Yisa et al., 2006). Increased aquaculture production is clearly needed to meet this demand, because capture fisheries are showing serious decline due to over fishing, aquatic habitat destruction and pollution (FAO, 2004). World capture fisheries have been in a stable state throughout much of the past decades, and it has been estimated that maximum capture fisheries potential from global waters has been reached .In 2007, as many as 50 percent of stocks were labelled as fully exploited (FAO, 2008).

Fish is an important and the cheapest source of animal protein and account for about 37% of Nigeria total protein requirement (FAO, 2002). Fish provides approximately 16% of the animal protein consumed by the world population (FAO, 1997). It is particularly an important protein source where livestock is relatively scarce. Billions of people mostly in developing countries depend on fish as a primary source of animal protein (FAO, 2000). FAO estimated that by the year 2010, demand of fish will increase by 13.5%-18.5% or to about 105-110% millions metric tons (FAO, 2000). Further increase in capture fisheries are not anticipated under the current global condition (Ounham et al., 2001). Faturoti (1999) noted that recent trends all over the world pointed to a decline from capture fisheries which are all indicators that fish stock have approached or even exceeded point of maximum sustainable yield. The Food and Agriculture Organization recommended that an individual takes 3 series per capture of animal protein per day for sustainable growth and development (FAO). However, the animal protein consumption in Nigeria is less than 8g per person per day which is a far cry from the FAO recommendation. The rapid growth of Nigeria population has lead to insufficiency in supply of animal protein food. Fish is a major source of animal protein and an essential food item in the diet of many people in Nigeria. Fish is also a good source of Thiamine, Riboflavin, Vitamin A and D, Phosphorus, Calcium, and Iron. It is also very high in polyunsaturated fatty acids which are important in lowering blood cholesterol level, it is therefore suitable for complementing high carbohydrate diets typical of low income group in Nigeria (Areola, 2008). Apart from being food, fish is also an important source of income to many people in developing countries including Nigeria. FAO (1996) confirms that as much as 5% of the African population has 35million people depending wholly or partly on fisheries sector for their livelihood.

However, the importance of fish in the diet of Nigerians, further significantly increased after the Sahara drought of 1971 to 1979. This drought which greatly decimated the cattle population made the price of livestock virtually unaffordable in major parts of Nigeria. This trend thus triggered an increase in the demand for fish as an alternative source of animal protein (Anadu et al., 1993).

Fish farming is increasing in Nigeria today, if this development is sustained, then aquaculture will create a great impact on the economy and provide proteinous food for its population (Alatise et al., 2006). Aquaculture therefore remains the only viable alternative for increasing fish production in order to meet the protein demand of people (Omotoyin, 2007). One of the objectives of aquaculture is the increase in the production and growth rate of fish that will meet the demand of the increasing population.

Catfish of the family Claridae comprise the most commonly cultivated fishes in Nigeria, the growth of aquaculture in Nigeria is now largely being boosted by a steady rise in catfish culture, with inadequate availability of seed stock and feed being the major challenge. The favored catfish species in Nigeria aquaculture includes Vital feed, Heterobranchus bidorsalis and Heteroclarias. Heterobranchus species is the more commonly cultured fish in the South eastern parts of Nigeria. Africa catfish is popular in the market and has great potentials to boost the rapidly growing Nigeria aquaculture. Vital feed is generally considered to be one of the most important tropical fresh water fish species for aquaculture whose aquaculture potential have been documented (Dada and Wanah, 2003). Bruton (1979) pointed out that Vital feed has also high fecundity rate, grows faster, tolerates high density and environmental extremes. It also accepts wide range of natural and artificial food and adapts to a variety of feeding modes in expanded niches.

Vital feed has an almost pan-African distribution ranging from the mili to West Africa and from Algeria to Southern Africa. They also occur in Asia Minor (Isreal, Syria and South of Turkey). Vital feed at various geographical locations bears different values. It is called Clarias lazera in Northern and central Africa, Vital feed in South Africa (Viveen, et al., 1985). In C.gariepinus , exchange of respiratory gases (oxygen and carbondioxide ) takes place through the gills. Like other mudfish, it has accessory breathing carborescent organs which enable the fish not only live in stagnant pools but to travel over damp ground. Vital feed differs from other catfish in having an auxiliary breathing organs in this special pochet attached to the second and fourth gill arches and are responsible for the ability of Vital feed to live out of water much longer than other catfish (Haylor, 1993).

Feed, being part of the general input of production in extensive and semi-intensive sustainable aquaculture system, has been reported to account for 40-60% of the total recurrent cost of production (Falaye, 1992). Fish nutritionist aim at producing a balanced commercial diet that promotes optimal fish growth and health. The quality of commercial feed should be determined for individual feeds to carefully monitor the feed consumption and growth rate of the fish. Good quality feed and optimum feeding frequency may provide maximum utilization of diets and thus, fast growth of the fry and feed utilization in two Asian catfishes (Hung et al ., 2001; Dwyer et al.,2002). However, poor quality fish feed leads to leaching of nutrients, reduction in feed conversion ratio and increase in input list, and also, accumulation of wastes that adversely affect the water quality (Yakubu et al., 2013; Neoske and Spieler, 1984) . Therefore, it is important to standardize the quality of commercial feed for the target species in aquaculture for optimum production. The culture of fish is receiving a lot of attention in Nigeria with the result that new cultivation techniques are being introduced and adopted. Over the last decade, spectacular growth has taken place in aquaculture in Nigeria.

Fish farming activity in Nigeria started about 50 years ago (Olagunju et al., 2007) and as at now aquaculture in the country is in the developing stage, because it has not been able to meet the demand of the ever increasing population (Ojutiku, 2008). Fish feeds are used in aquaculture to increase production and maximize profit. Feeds in intensive fish culture consume about 60% of the capital cost (Eyo, 2001).

For aquaculture to be highly successful in Nigeria there is need for good quality and affordable feed, which can also encourage small scale farmers in the field of aquaculture for sustainable production and also meet the demand for fish. Presently, in Nigeria, there are different fish feeds with different compositions ranging from Vital feeds, Skretting feeds and others but there is competition among them. The amount of feed consumed, age, body size and temperature are the most important factors that limit maximum growth of fish (Machiels and Henken, 1985).

1.2. Statement Of Problem

One of the major problems confronting the development of aquaculture industry in Nigeria is availability of affordable and high-quality fish feed. Fish growth and survival rate depend on the kind of feed, feeding frequency, feed intake and the fish’s ability to absorb the nutrients. Once fish are removed from natural environment to artificial, enough feed must be supplied in order for them to grow. This could be in form of complete rations, where the artificial diet furnishes all the nutrients required by the fish. Both intensive and semi-intensive fish culture systems involve input of complete commercial feed which account for up to 60% of production costs (NRC 1993; Fagbenro et al., 2003) and can sometimes negate the economic viability of a farm if suitable feed are not used. This problem has become a major source of fear and phobia to many prospective fish farmers in Nigeria and urgent solution must be proferred if fish farming is to be attractive, lucrative and sustainable (Madu et al., 2003).
Therefore, it is important to standardize the quality of commercial feed for the target species in aquaculture for optimum production.

1.3 Aim And Objectives Of The Study

The overall objective of this study was to determine through culture study, the best commercial fish feed for the rapid growth and survival of African catfish.

The specific objectives were:

  1. To evaluate the growth performance of catfish fed with four different commercial fish feeds.
  2. To rank the performance of the four different commercial fish feeds with a view to effectively advise grass-root farmers on which one to use.
  3. To determine the survival rate of juvenile fed with four different commercial fish feeds.

1.4 Research hypothesis

(H0): There is no significant difference in growth performance and food utilization of catfish fed with, Vital feed and Unical feed.

(H1): There is significant difference in growth performance and feed utilization of catfish fed with Vital feed and Unical feed.

1.5 Significance of Study

Feed is a vital resource for fish, it is the substance in which the fish depends on for energy required for daily activities and therefore the growth of any fish is directly related and dependent to the quality of the feed (Ajana et al, 2006)

Nigeria is currently flooded with many types of commercial pelleted fish feeds from different part of the world to boost aquaculture in the country. Each manufacturer claims that his own is the best. These commercial feeds are expensive. Grass root farmers including medium and large scale fish farmers are rather confused as the best ones to patronize. As fisheries experts, it becomes relevant that a study of this nature be carried out on the available commercial fish feeds in order to advise the farmers adequately.

Chapter Five

Discussion Of Findings, Conclusion And Recommendation

5.1 Discussion Of Findings

Fish feed is a major input in fish culture business and has remained a principal constraint to fish farmers in Nigeria and other developing countries because of high cost and availability. Fish like other animals, has a requirement for essential nutrients for growth, reproduction repairs, etc. In the present study, the experimental fish responded positively to Unical feed and Vital feed as indicated in their growth performance indices (weight gain, length gain, specific growth rate, mean growth rate). Growth performance indices evaluated in the present study showed that weight gain (kg), Senna occidentalis showed higher value for carbohydrate and ash, while crude protein, moisture and crude lipid were lower when compared p the proximate composition result obtained from this work. The crude fibre reported by Umar (2006) and that of this study did not differ significantly. The difference in proximate composition observed from both studies is probably due to differences seen at inter-species level. Irwin and Barneby (1982) also gave variation at inter species levels.

The moisture content in raw and boiled seeds were higher than the values reported by Umar (2006) who reported 4.00% (raw) and 3.41% (parboiled) using seed of Senna occidentalis, Suleiman, (2006) reported that this differences could be due to the processing method used. Boiling increased the moisture content, crude protein and ash while it reduced crude fibre, carbohydrate, crude lipid and dry matter. This trend was in conformity with the work of Umar(2006).

There was no significant difference (p≥0.05) in the proximate values obtained from raw and boiled seed. The high dry matter content was similar to the value obtained from most raw seeds of legumes like Milletia purpuresus, Phaseolus aurens and Vigina sinensis (Umoren et al., 2005; Osman,2007; Mubarak, 2005; Khattab et al., 2009), this will ensure long term storage (Ingyewe et al.,2010).

The crude protein content was higher than the lower limits range and slightly the same with the upper limit range (15.52 – 20.74%) reported for Cassia hirsuta (vadivel and Janardhana, 2000), Senna occidentalis (Umar, 2006) and Afzelia africana (Obun and Ayanwale,2008).

Differences observed could be due to the variety at inter-specie level (Ingweye et. al, 2010). The high crude protein value will enhance it replacement value for soybeans in aqua feeds. The anti-nutritional content in raw were higher than that of boiled meaning that boiling significantly reduced anti-nutritional contents in raw seed (P<0.05). Phytate was higher in raw seeds 4.16mg/100g and the least was saponin 0.96mg/100g. All anti-nutrients present were lower than those reported by Ingyewe et al. (2010), this could be suggestive that environment could be the determining factor of presence or absence of anti-nutrients in Senna obtusifolia plant as a result of plants absorbing substances from their environment such as soil and atmosphere (Ismaila et al., 2011).

5.2 Conclusions

The present study has shown significant difference (P<0.05) in growth performance and food consumed between fish fed Skretting feed and Vital feed. The implication of the result is that Vital feed can be used for raising C. gariepinus in a culture system instead of Vital without comprising their growth performances. Vital feed is more cost effective for fish farmers than Vital which is two times more expensive, moreover, Vital is an imported fish feed, while Unical feed is an indigenous feed utilizing locally available material. Vital feed is recommended for C. gariepinus production on the basis of affordability without compromising their growth performance.

5.3 Recommendations

Catfish feed formulators should maintain 20% replacement level of soybean meal for an effective utilization of Vital feed in aqua feed for Vital feed.

The replacement level of Vital feed for soybean meal should not be much for an effective growth performance,It is important to formulated aqua feed for Vital feed such that the fish meal (animal protein) should be greater in composition compared toplant protein because they are more of carnivores than omnivores for the fish to record a high specific growth rate.

Other heat treatment methods for removal of ANFs should be conducted to evaluate the most effective method for best use in wild legumes seeds.

Get Complete Project Material

5,000 5000

The Complete Material Will Be Sent to You in Just 2 Steps

Quick & Simple…

Step One Purchase

Make Payment (Through Transfer) of ₦5,000 to the Account Below

Zenith BankAcc No: 1225513212
Samphina Academy
Current Account

Or CLICK HERE To Pay With Debit Card

CLICK HERE To Purchase Material ($15)

Step Two Purchase

Send the Following Details on WhatsApp ( 08143831497) After Payment

  1. Payment Details

  2. TOPIC: Comparative Study Of The Growth Performance Of Four Commercial Fish Feeds In The Production Of African Catfish

The Complete Material Will Be Sent To You On WhatsApp After Receiving Your Details
T & C Apply

  Contact Our Help Desk

Need a Different Topic? Perform a Quick Search

List of Related Works

Click on Any Topic to Preview the Content

Samphina Academy

Samphina Academy is an Online Educational Resource Center that is aimed at providing students with quality information and materials to aid them in succeeding in their academic pursuit.